| | 2006 Alexander Ovechkin Washington Capitals |
| | 2004 Andrew Raycroft Boston Bruins |
| | 2003 Barett Jackman St. Louis Blues |
| | 2002 Dany Heatley Atlanta Thrashers |
| | 2001 Evgeni Nabokov San Jose Sharks |
| | 2000 Scott Gomez New Jersey Devils |
| | 1999 Chris Drury Colorado Avalanche |
| | 1998 Sergei Samsonov Boston Bruins |
| | 1997 Bryan Berard New York Islanders |
| | 1996 Daniel Alfredsson Ottawa Senators |
| | 1995 Peter Forsberg Quebec Nordiques |
| | 1994 Martin Brodeur New Jersey Devils |
| | 1993 Teemu Selanne Winnipeg Jets |
| | 1992 Pavel Bure Vancouver Canucks |
| | 1991 Ed Belfour Chicago Blackhawks |
| | 1990 Sergei Makarov Calgary Flames |
| | 1989 Brian Leetch New York Rangers |
| | 1988 Joe Nieuwendyk Calgary Flames |
| | 1987 Luc Robitaille Los Angeles Kings |
| | 1986 Gary Suter Calgary Flames |
| | 1985 Mario Lemieux Pittsburgh Penguins |
| | 1984 Tom Barrasso Buffalo Sabres |
| | 1983 Steve Larmer Chicago Black Hawks |
| | 1982 Dale Hawerchuk Winnipeg Jets |
| | 1981 Peter Stastny Quebec Nordiques |
| | 1980 Ray Bourque Boston Bruins |
| | 1979 Bobby Smith Minnesota North Stars |
| | 1978 Mike Bossy New York Islanders |
| | 1977 Willi Plett Atlanta Flames |
| | 1976 Bryan Trottier New York Islanders |
| | 1975 Eric Vail Atlanta Flames |
| | 1974 Denis Potvin New York Islanders |
| | 1973 Steve Vickers New York Rangers |
| | 1972 Ken Dryden Montreal Canadiens |
| | 1971 Gilbert Perreault Buffalo Sabres |
| | 1970 Tony Esposito Chicago Black Hawks |
| | 1969 Danny Grant Minnesota North Stars |
| | 1968 Derek Sanderson Boston Bruins |
| | 1967 Bobby Orr Boston Bruins |
| | 1966 Brit Selby Toronto Maple Leafs |
| | 1965 Roger Crozier Detroit Red Wings |
| | 1964 Jacques Laperriere Montreal Canadiens |
| | 1963 Kent Douglas Toronto Maple Leafs |
| | 1962 Bobby Rousseau Montreal Canadiens |
| | 1961 Dave Keon Toronto Maple Leafs |
| | 1960 Bill Hay Chicago Black Hawks |
| | 1959 Ralph Backstrom Montreal Canadiens |
| | 1958 Frank Mahovlich Toronto Maple Leafs |
| | 1957 Larry Regan Boston Bruins |
| | 1956 Glenn Hall Detroit Red Wings |
| | 1955 Ed Litzenberger Chicago Black Hawks |
| | 1954 Camille Henry New York Rangers |
| | 1953 Lorne Worsley New York Rangers |
| | 1952 Bernie Geoffrion Montreal Canadiens |
| | 1951 Terry Sawchuk Detroit Red Wings |
| | 1950 Jack Gelineau Boston Bruins |
| | 1949 Pentti Lund New York Rangers |
| | 1948 Jim McFadden Detroit Red Wings |
| | 1947 Howie Meeker Toronto Maple Leafs |
| | 1946 Edgar Laprade New York Rangers |
| | 1945 Frank McCool Toronto Maple Leafs |
| | 1944 Gus Bodnar Toronto Maple Leafs |
| | 1943 Gaye Stewart Toronto Maple Leafs |
| | 1942 Grant Warwick New York Rangers |
| | 1941 Johnny Quilty Montreal Canadiens |
| | 1940 Kilby MacDonald New York Rangers |
| | 1939 Frank Brimsek Boston Bruins |
| | 1938 Cully Dahlstrom Chicago Black Hawks |
| | 1937 Syl Apps Toronto Maple Leafs |
| | 1936 Mike Karakas Chicago Black Hawks |
| | 1935 Dave Schriner New York Americans |
| | 1934 Russ Blinko Montreal Maroons |
| | 1933 Carl Voss Detroit Red Wings |