| | 1816-1817 Jarvis W. Pike |
| | 1818-1819 John Kerr |
| | 1820-1822 Eli C. King |
| | 1823 Tom Laughery |
| | 1824-1826 William T. Martin |
| | 1827 James Robinson |
| | 1827-1833 William Long |
| | 1833 Philo H. Olmsted |
| | 1834 John Brooks |
| | 1835 John Bailhache - Whig |
| | 1836-1837 Warren Jenkins - Whig |
| | 1838-1839 Philo H. Olmstead (2nd) - Whig |
| | 1840 John G. Miller - Whig |
| | 1841 Thomas Wood |
| | 1842 Abram Irvin McDowell |
| | 1843 Smithson E. Wright - Whig |
| | 1845 Alexander Patton |
| | 1846 Augustus Stoner Decker - Whig |
| | 1847-1849 Alexander Patton (2nd) |
| | 1850-1861 Lorenzo English - Whig |
| | 1861-1864 Wray Thomas - Peace Democrat |
| | 1865-1868 James G. Bull - Democratic |
| | 1869-1870 George W. Meeker - Democratic |
| | 1871-1874 James G. Bull (2nd) |
| | 1875-1878 John H. Heitmann |
| | 1879-1880 Gilbert G. Collins |
| | 1881-1882 George Silas Peters - Democratic |
| | 1883-1886 Charles C. Walcutt - Republican |
| | 1887-1890 Philip H. Bruck - Democratic |
| | 1893-1894 George J. Karb |
| | 1895-1896 Cotton Hayden Allen - Democratic |
| | 1897-1898 Samuel L. Black - Democratic |
| | 1899-1900 Samuel Jackson Swartz - Republican |
| | 1901-1902 John Nelson Hinkle - Democratic |
| | 1903-1905 Robert H. Jeffrey - Republican |
| | 1906-1907 DeWitt Clinton Badger - Democratic |
| | 1908-1909 Charles Anson Bond - Republican |
| | 1910-1911 George Sidney Marshall - Republican |
| | 1912-1919 George J. Karb (2nd) |
| | 1920-1931 James John Thomas - Republican |
| | 1932-1935 Henry William Worley - Democratic |
| | 1936-1939 Myron B. Gessaman - Republican |
| | 1940-1943 Floyd F. Green - Republican |
| | 1944-1952 James A. Rhodes - Republican |
| | 1953 Robert Theodore Oestreicher - Republican |
| | 1954-1959 Maynard Edward "Jack" Sensenbrenner - Democratic |
| | 1960-1963 Wallace Ralston Westlake - Republican |
| | 1964-1971 Maynard Edward "Jack" Sensenbrenner (2nd) - Democratic |
| | 1972-1982 Thomas Moody - Republican |
| | 1983-1991 Dana G. "Buck" Rinehart - Republican |
| | 1992-1999 Gregory S. Lashutka - Republican |
| | 2000-present Michael B. Coleman - Democratic |